Friday, June 6, 2014

Review: Responsible Travel Guide Cambodia

I bought this book out of curiosity, because it's hard to find reliable Cambodia resources. My feelings are mixed, partly because the book itself is a kitchen-sink mixture of information about various aspects of Cambodia, its history, travel information, and nonprofit organizations.

It's available through the nonprofit that wrote it, Friendship With Cambodia, for $11.95 plus $3 s/h (the site says $14.95, but if you click the Paypal link it charges a lower price). You can read a sample here. Since the book is $14.05 currently via amazon, I encourage you to buy via the nonprofit's site. There are corrections and additions, current as of March 2014, available on the nonprofit site as well. This is very useful, since businesses in Cambodia can be fleeting and the problem with any travel guide is its relevance. Edit: It's also available as a $6 ebook from the main page of the site, not the book page, if you scroll down. Very confusing.

Who should read this book?

Anyone who is traveling to Cambodia, especially the main areas of Siem Reap and Phnom Penh, and wants to spend their money responsibly either by shopping, dining, or staying in franchises that support Cambodia and whose money does not leave Cambodia. Anyone who wants a general overview of Cambodia the country, including travel information, timelines and history, and customs.

How useful is the information in the book?

As a travel guide, the book has a strange melange of information. I think it's worth knowing some decent places to spend money while in Cambodia. You may pay a higher price but you can feel good about where your money went. However, the book fails as a travel guide in two major areas. 

First, it doesn't include enough information about what to see in Cambodia. For instance, the Phnom Penh section highlights the "cultural treasures of the Royal Palace" and the "outstanding collection of ancient sculpture at the National Museum" (11). It includes a suggested three-day itinerary with bullet points such as "Visit the National Museum (ancient sculpture)" without saying anything more about the National Museum (11). For opening times, more details about its exhibits such as what famous/recommended pieces are in the museum or even what there is besides sculpture and more logistical information, you need to do further research. That's fine if you're planning a trip, but not so great if you are in Cambodia and chose to make this guide your only in-country resource.

Second, it is not comprehensive. You can, as long as you are willing to pay slightly more, get along only patronizing the recommended establishments in Siem Reap or Phnom Penh, but I would have liked more comprehensive coverage of other regions or nods to other choices which, if not worthy of a 'responsible' label, would guarantee that a traveler could get along solely with this book.

As an informational resource about volunteering in Cambodia or making an altruistic impact, the book seems to have succeeded. Though I would have liked a list of organizations and tourist traps to avoid, they cover topics such as sex tourism, the exploitation of children, and reliable places to volunteer along with contact information and what type of volunteers the places need (including length of stay). Since Cambodian websites are sometimes untranslated, poorly-formatted, and full of uninformation, I'm very happy I bought the book.

As an informational resource about Cambodia, the book is a mixed bag. Basic information about customs and holidays lives side-by-side with a heart-wrenching 'sample' account of a survivor of the Pol Pot era. The food section is more an infographic than a real guide with names and recommendations, and given the difficulties of Cambodian script and the often vaguely-translated menus for tourists, a detailed menu guide would have been appreciated here. There's a basic section with a few Khmer phrases, but no guide as to pronunciation. In general, I would have liked the information included to be more focused, both on the travel aspects of the book and on the education about Cambodia. Most of the information isn't as good as what you would find in a Lonely Planet introduction, for instance. However, it is more comprehensive and focuses more on responsible tourism than a LP guide would.

The book also includes a bibliography of books about Cambodia, a good starting point for further reading.

Conclusion:

Any travel guide should include more details about food, places to stay, tourist attractions, and alternative options, especially in a country where public internet is tricky and expensive, and corruption runs rampant. The book is clearly the work of a team of amateurs; some of the sections seem included just because someone wanted to write them, and others could have used a critical eye to amend some of the glaring omissions or lack of specificity that plagues the guide. It's put out by an organization that deals intimately with Cambodia, not a worldwide organization that can't afford to check out Cambodia-specific venues, so its generality is disappointing.

Also, the guide does recommend some travel tour companies with Cambodian offices, but if you check out the Friendship with Cambodia website, you'll see that they run a tour of their own. I appreciate the parity in recommending other tours, but the book does serve to advertise the Friendship with Cambodia tour and encourage readers to donate to its programs and buy its book of Khmer Rouge survivor accounts (hence the sample excerpt). I would have preferred more information and less advertising, but I will probably buy and review their other book to support this worthy nonprofit.


Friday, May 30, 2014

Financial Update

Here's an update about finances, since we have new contribution information!
--------------------------------
Original Budget:
Flight $1800
Baggage Fee $150
Visa $25
Ground transportation $50
School Supplies $250

Living Expenses $900

Total: $3175

Funds:
Indiegogo $1723.36
Donations: $100

Total: $1823.36
--------------------------------
Deficit: $1351.64

My Contribution: $1250

So I'm still a bit in the red. However, I plan to see how much I can raise on my own! Here are some of the ways I plan to put money aside:

  • Selling assets
  • Grants and funding
  • Odd jobs
  • Saving each month (which I have already started)
  • Birthday contributions
  • Garage sale!
I'm hopeful that I'll be able to make up the difference, and I'll have more information soon about how to get a souvenir, how to contribute now that the campaign is over, and what my plans are! This is the beginning of an exciting time.

Again, thanks to everyone who helped out!

Wednesday, May 28, 2014

Donor Acknowledgements!

Hello everyone!

Here's the blog shout-out that I promised you. For those of you who chose to remain anonymous (even though I know who you are), if you want an acknowledgement just send me a message and let me know!

First, a fuzzy shout-out to my anonymous funders:

Family and friends, thank you all! I couldn't have done this without you. I'll be keeping in touch when it comes time to leave, and I appreciate what you've done, even if it's behind the scenes. People in <Aisthesis>, sorry about losing your GM for a couple of weeks and putting up with our officer corps running things, but let it be known that your suffering will be for a good cause!

Thanks to:
RBR
Grace
Harmony
Aunt Tess
Super-nova
Darren
My wonderful godparents
Uncle Rudy
Uncle Steve and Aunt Debbie, who chose to send checks rather than contribute on Indiegogo, adding to my campaign total after the fact!

And of course my parents and boyfriend, who have pledged their support to me and contributed in ways that go beyond donations.

Thanks to everyone who shared my link and put up with my social media spamming (sorry!).

*A special thanks to Daharel, who pestered the people around him tirelessly in support of my cause.*

For those of you who want a Cambodian souvenir, I'll be working out details in the upcoming months. Please follow my blog for details about trip planning, syllabus planning, and goodies!

Tuesday, May 20, 2014

And, we're done!

It's late, so this will be brief--but a huge thank you post is coming later, plus the blog acknowledgements for anyone who donated who chose to put their name on their donation.

After fees, my campaign raised $1784.51. (Edit: I forgot about Paypal fees on top of regular fees. The actual amount is $1723.86). I'm thrilled that we made it as far as we did. That puts the sum total of positive projected money at $3035 (Edit: $2974), if I throw in a contribution of $1250.49 (Edit: $2973.36) (I have some spare change somewhere, I'm sure).

Money: $2974
Estimated Cost: $3175

Total: -$201

As I said this weekend, a deficit is somewhat of a big deal, because making my portion of the bargain isn't a number I came up with spontaneously, but a monthly target. I plan to sell some assets and to work as much as I can given my schedule. However, I think everything will work out in the end. Either I will not end up bringing donations with me (I was planning on bringing a beat-up suitcase and leaving it there) or I'll bring a small bag's worth. It really depends on the cost of the lesson plan materials on my syllabus. But anyway, here's what having the money allows me to do:

1) Talk to the school and commit to dates. I'm so, so, so happy about this.
2) Start planning lessons based on what they expect me to do.
3) Figure out my end of the finances.

To everyone who wished me well, even if you didn't donate, you're the best. Thank you all so much. I'll be rolling out the red carpet for my donors in the coming days.

Friday, May 16, 2014

My Indiegogo Campaign Closes on 5/19/14

Hello everyone!

I'm so excited about the campaign contributions I've received so far, but my campaign is about to come to an end, and I need your help! Please like, share, and donate if you can. I've thought about my budget and put the conclusions below. If you don't want to read about the itemization and rationales, just skip to the summary section. Thanks for reading!

Current Budget
+
Indiegogo $1826-FEES=$1661
Expected Contribution $1250
Total +: $2911

-
Flight $1800
Baggage Fee $150
Visa $25
Ground transportation $50
School Supplies $250
Living Expenses $900
Total -: $3175

Total Difference:
-$264

So, I'm in the red. If I don't make my campaign goal, I get to keep the funds, but Indiegogo keeps 9% of the contributions instead of 4%. I knew that going in, but I decided to reach for the stars anyway.

Now, I know that some people may contribute to my campaign at a later date in a manner that doesn't involve fees. I would be very appreciative of that. $1250 is a stretch goal for me in terms of money to save up over the next few months, and I may have to push my travel time back a bit to help save over a longer period. When I outlined the budget on Indiegogo, I reached for the stars in terms of classroom materials and expected donations, whereas I went for almost the bare minimum when it comes to living expenses (I did opt for a place with hot water to live in, though). So the question would be, where to cut?

Sample Revised Budget
Flight $1800
Visa $25
Ground transportation $50

These three categories are set in stone, since I still need to get over there in order to teach.

Required Total: $1875

Baggage Fee $150
School Supplies $250
Living Expenses $900

Here's where things get tricky. I calculated living expenses for one month's worth of travel. Let's assume we're trying to keep that as long as we can, since length of stay > donations to school in this case.

I can pack the bare minimum, which means I won't be able to donate books and laptops to the school, but completely removes the baggage fee. I can also cut out the school donation, but I still need teaching supplies. Let's assume I can halve the supplies budget.

That leaves me at $1025, giving an overall expense of $2900 and making the campaign affordable.

If we go the other way and assume that I want to keep the donations, gifts, and VIP supplies, on the assumption that objects linger longer than presence, then I would have a starting cost of $400 plus living expenses. My total target is $1025, so I would have $625 to live on. When I calculated living expenses, I estimated $15/night for lodgings, and $15/day for food and transportation to and from the school, which is doable. How many days, then, could I afford to stay?

The answer is 20 days, so, with weekends, I would be able to teach for about two and a half weeks, but I would have to leave in the middle of a week.

Summary
What does that mean for you? It means that a donation of $30 adds an extra day to my trip, a donation of $150 guarantees I'll be able to collect items to donate and bring them safely with me to Cambodia, and a donation of $250 guarantees school supplies and a small donation to the school. Please do what you can. I appreciate it.

Tuesday, April 22, 2014

Campaign Update!

After a big push and some very generous donations, we're at the halfway mark for funding! Getting my volunteering project off the ground is looking more realistic by the day. I'm certainly excited to start making concrete plans. I would love to get fully funded, but I'm so thrilled at the response thus far. 

I'll be getting ready to make the final campaign push from the Starry Night Artist Retreat in New Mexico, including reaching out to people personally. Please donate or spread the word! 

Friday, April 4, 2014

Thanks to everyone who has donated so far!

I'm really happy with the campaign results, and I'm hoping that more people will take notice and donate! There's still 45 days remaining, so I'm optimistic that I can reach my goal. If I don't, all the donations I've received will still matter to me, and that's what's important.

I'll probably do all of the blog shout outs in one post, but if you have donated and you are looking for your shout out, I will notify you once it's done!

Wish me luck!